Monday, January 2, 2017

WILL EUROPE'S DISINTEGRATION ACCELERATE IN 2017?

During the Summer of 1971 I spent three months in Western Europe interviewing politicians and labor leaders as part of a research project designed to evaluate the level of opposition to the concept and implementation of the European integration process, which, at the time, was still in its infancy. Some were entirely opposed to the idea of giving up national independence and identity, others were concerned that the process was not taking place fast enough. On balance, the objective of creating a European Union was accepted as inevitably necessary to prevent a recurrence of the wars that wrecked the European continent throughout history.

That was 45 years ago. The initial alliance was created by the Treaty of Rome in 1958, and included Germany, France, Italy, Belgium, The Netherlands and Luxembourg, and would not be expanded until shortly after I spent my time there. The U.K., Ireland and Denmark joined January 1, 1973, and during subsequent decades the European Union expanded to include 28 member states. The optimistically anticipated inevitability of progress towards an ever-intensifying union did not materialize as smoothly as expected, however. The Schengen Agreements, which eliminated internal border checks and allowed free movement throughout the E.U., signed in 1985 and effective 1995, still suggested significant unanimity, even though the U.K., Ireland, and a few Eastern European members did not sign on. The 1999 roll-out of the Euro, intended to become the official currency of the Union, only attracted 19 members. But the big challenge came in 2004 when the European Parliament attempted to pass a treaty that would have established a constitution for Europe. This constitution was designed to replace existing treaties with a single document, and, among other things, allow for qualified majority voting to replace henceforth mandated unanimity requirements. But French and Dutch voters, in a referendum, voted against adoption, and killed the proposal.

One could argue over why the progression towards the establishment of a unified European state slowed, came to a halt, and regressed. Expansion may have been too great and too fast. New members were likely seduced by anticipated benefits of economic integration, but less inclined to relinquish much of their political independence. The rule that all states had to agree before new policies could be adopted stymied progress. More recently, however, several other significant issues accelerated the disintegration of what, up to then, had grown into one of the most important economic and political powers in the world. The 2008 recession identified a debt crisis in a number of, mostly Southern European, countries, placing significant stress on the Euro-Zone, and illuminating systemic problems within the organization. The overwhelming flood of migrants coming in from the Middle-East and Northern Africa put the continued desirability of the Schengen Agreements to the test, while strengthening nationalist and populist political movements in many member countries. The politicization of these influences created a crisis within the organization, which, in 2017, may well accelerate its disintegration.

In June of 2016 the U.K. voted to leave the Union. In January the British Supreme Court will deliver their verdict on whether Prime Minister Theresa May can use the "royal prerogative" and begin Brexit negotiations with the E.U. without approval of Parliament. If she is not allowed to, members could actually vote against the onset of negotiations and block exit from the Union. In March, in a general election, Dutch voters are expected to give Geert Wilders' anti-E.U., anti-immigrant, anti-Muslim Party For Freedom a majority in its House of Representatives. If he succeeds, the Dutch may also be asked to vote to leave the E.U.. France's presidential election is scheduled for April 23 (primary) and May 7 (general). Marine Le Pen, leader of the National Front, has a real chance of taking over the country's presidency. If she does, she has promised to hold a referendum on a French exit (Frexit). Germany holds its general election sometime between late Summer and early Fall. The nationalist AfD (Alternative for Germany), anti-E.U., anti-immigrant and anti-Muslim party will likely give Angela Merkel's Christian Democrats a run for their money. Italy's Prime Minister Matteo Renzi's recent resignation has left the door wide open for Beppe Grillo's Five Star Movement in an election that could take place later this year. Greece may be headed towards an election as well, since there are signs that Prime Minister Alexis Tsirpas seems to be positioning himself to defy his government's debt restructuring agreement with the European Central Bank.
And so it goes.

Whether the European Union will survive the populist onslaught remains to be seen. Thus far it survived many of the financial skirmishes resulting from the recession in 2008, even though significant debt related systemic issues remain. The more immediate, political, challenges confronting the organization are concentrated in many of its member states, and can't be resolved within its supranational structure. It is telling that roughly one third of the 751 members of the European Parliament are considered "eurosceptic." High unemployment, coupled with a growing refugee crisis affecting most member states, led to the election of these, essentially anti-E.U., MEPs. The average unemployment rate within the E.U. still approaches 10%, with Greece exceeding 23% and Spain hovering around 19%. These statistics won't diminish voter displeasure. The flood of non-European migrants, which produced a cultural identity crisis in many member states, is giving the political parties these eurosceptic MEPs represent the ammunition they need to advance their agenda. Those need to be dealt with in-country, and those are the ones that can eventually further the disintegration of the European idea. Poland and Hungary, countries which joined the E.U. as recently as 2002 and 2004, are already run by eurosceptic governments. Those are the movements to watch.

The next election for the European Parliament won't take place until 2019. A lot can happen between now and then. For those who don't think this issue is important to us, that Europe is far away, and what happens there won't really affect us, just consider that between the U.S. and the E.U. we transact about $1 trillion in business every year, that together we represent 60% of global GDP, that, strategically, we built the strongest military defense alliance in the world, and, as a bloc, we play a leading role in international relations. Disintegration will only benefit our adversaries. It will severely, negatively, affect our national interest.

Monday, December 19, 2016

EMBRACING NOSTALGIA ALLOWS US TO DECOMPRESS

A few weeks ago, while erecting our Christmas tree, listening to Christmas carols, and inhaling the scent of cookies baking in the oven, I was overcome by an overwhelming sense of nostalgia. With everything our minds have been preoccupied with this past year, and with all the challenging issues at home and abroad that will confront us in the coming year, this sensation actually felt tremendously comforting, be it somewhat melancholic. It occurred to me that, perhaps, this is exactly what we as a community and as a nation need right now - enjoy the season, take some time off, and reflect on what has always made us feel safe and comfortable.

While processing this experience I recognized intuitively that in my mind "nostalgia" contains characteristics that are largely positive and beneficial.

The dictionary definition of nostalgia is "a wistful or excessively sentimental yearning to or of some past period or irrecoverable condition," sometimes enhanced by a "yearning for the happiness felt in a former place, time or situation." However, for centuries, giving into feelings of nostalgia was considered a sign of weakness.

The word originated from the Greek for "homecoming" and "pain." Throughout most of the 19th Century this sensation was considered a potentially debilitating, and sometimes fatal, medical condition, expressing extreme homesickness. (Melissa Dahl, "The Little-Known Medical History of Homesickness," February, 2016). A Swiss medical student, Johannes Hofer, first defined nostalgia in a dissertation he wrote in 1688. He defined it as a mental illness, an affliction of those who had left their home, and which struck them as they recalled fond memories. In some cases they were crippled by the sense of longing these memories brought. His research focused on Swiss mercenaries fighting abroad. Consequently, early on, nostalgia was often referred to as the "Swiss disease." The characteristics Hofer identified and discussed were recognized well before he published his dissertation.

During the Thirty Years War - which ran from 1618 to 1648, involving much of central and southern Europe, Spanish soldiers were discharged from service because they suffered so strongly from it that they were no longer capable of fighting. During the early 1700s, Russian troops were often buried alive if they succumbed to the so-called nostalgia virus. And during the U.S. Civil War, soldiers who grew nostalgic for their homes and families were publicly shamed and ridiculed until they got over it. (Debra Kelly, "When Nostalgia Was Considered A Crippling Mental Illness," June 29, 2014).

These days nostalgia is viewed as an independent, and even positive, emotion many people tend to experience frequently. Led by University of Southampton psychologist Constantine Sedikides, scientists focus on its potentially therapeutic aspects. Research suggests that nostalgia can promote psychological health, including counteracting the effects of loneliness and providing us with a greater sense of continuity and meaning to our lives. It seems to help us maintain a sense of who we are, and how we are connected to other people through our relationships. Participation in religious traditions or cultural norms, especially during the Holiday season, helps us do that. (Krystine Batcho, "Why We Feel Nostalgic During The Holidays," New York, Le Moyne College, December 20, 2011).

This past year has been stressful for many of us. The daily bombardment of controversial input, emanating from a brutal election campaign, caused many relationships to become severely frayed. A post-election article in the Boston Globe stated that the mental health of Americans of all persuasions had been seriously challenged. The National Suicide Prevention Lifeline and other hot line services reported huge surges in calls for help.

As a result of all that we have been confronted with this past year, many of us have experienced the feeling of being disconnected from reality, and acknowledged that somehow we have been separated from some of our friends and family members. The feeling of nostalgia that may overpower us during this time of the year, if we allow ourselves to embrace it, could help us regain a margin of separation from all that befuddles us, while bringing us mentally back to a time when political and social distractions did not get in the way of our sanity. It can help make us feel grounded again, and provide continuity and context to our lives. If we feel we need it, it may even help give us the strength to move on. We will realize  that there will be ample time to confront and assess our challenges after the holidays.

Wishing everyone Merry Christmas, Happy Hanukkah, or Happy Kwanzaa, all of which this year are celebrated around the same time. They provide a fitting spiritual conclusion to a tumultuous year. I am confident that even those of us who don't subscribe to a religious tradition will still be inspired by the spirit of the season, and feel connected to all who surround us.

Saturday, December 3, 2016

ANXIETY AND XENOPHOBIA IN POST- ELECTION AMERICA

One of the troublesome aftermaths of a nationalist electoral victory continues to be that the victors, especially those who used to occupy the fringes of society, now feel emancipated and entitled to act on their nativist impulses and begin to attack minorities, immigrants, and basically anyone they don't like. Back in June, when many voters in the U.K., upset over what they believed was an unrestricted inflow of migrants, voted to leave the E.U., racist abuse increased almost 100% overnight. Much of this abuse was directed at Polish immigrants, many of whom had been British citizens for generations. Pamphleteers spread the word that now that the U.K. was leaving the E.U., its citizens no longer needed to tolerate "Polish varmint." Kids in school were told that they would be deported. Casual racism spread unchallenged.

Fast forward to our own post-election period. Two days after the election results were in, USA Today headlined: "Rise in racists acts follow elections." Educators were quoted suggesting that feelings that had festered for years in private were now coming into the open. A swastika was scrawled on a softball field dug-out in Wellsville, N.Y., accompanied by the slogan: "Make America White Again." In Maple Gove, Minn, messages on a high school bathroom wall included: "#gobacktoafrica," and #whitesonly." White students in De Witt, Mich. formed a physical wall of students to block Latino kids from entering school. A Muslin woman had a knife pulled on her in a bus by a Trump supporter. Several California Mosques received threatening letters stating: "Trump will do what Adolph Hitler did to the Jews." And a personal friend, who immigrated many years ago, who built a successful business, and who employs many in our community, has been confronted by people coming into her business telling her in no uncertain terms: "Go home!"

The Southern Poverty Law Center tracked more than 80 reported hate crime and racist incidents in California between Nov. 9 and 16, the most of any state. The pattern is not just disturbing, it is scary.

Whether President-Elect Donald Trump can stem this tide is questionable. After all, candidate Trump provided ample ammunition for these hate groups. In November last year, on the MSNBC "Morning Joe" program, Trump vowed to build a "deportation force" and deport 11 million undocumented immigrants from the country. That same month Trump confirmed that he would "absolutely require Muslims to register in a data-base." One of his surrogates, Carl Higbie, representing the biggest Super-Pac supporting candidate Trump, reiterated this intent, and suggested that the Japanese internment camps could serve as legal precedent for establishing a Muslim registry. During a subsequent interview on "Meet the Press," incoming White House Chief of Staff Reince Priebus appeared to confirm this when he stated that he "would not rule anything out."

The selection of Stephen Bannon as President Trump's Chief Strategist and Senior Counselor has dampened the hopes of many that Mr. Trump's transition to President-Elect and President would somehow prompt a softening of the populist and nativist positions he ran on when he was still a mere candidate for the office. Only two years ago, in an email to supporters, Bannon wrote: "Let the grassroots turn on the hate, because that's the only thing that will make them do their duty." In his role as (former) Executive Chairman of the Breitbart New, Bannon is known for statements like: 'Birth control makes women unattractive and crazy," calling Bill Kristol - editor of the Weekly Standard - a Republican spoiler  and a renegade Jew," claiming that Huma Abedin, aide to Hillary Clinton, is connected to a terrorist conspiracy, and calling progressive women "a bunch of dykes."

People like Richard Spencer, leader of the so-called "alt-right" movement, a distinctly white supremacist organization, for which, according to Mr. Bannon, the Breitbart News provides a platform, rejoiced at the appointment. During a Nov. 19 meeting in Washington D.C., Mr. Spencer suggested that the "alt-right" could serve as "an intellectual vanguard" that would complete Trump. He hoped that they could be "the ones who are out front, and who are thinking about things that he (Trump) hasn't grasped yet." He ended his speech, appropriately, with the Nazi salute: "Hail Trump!"

Six days after the election, former House Speaker Newt Gingrich declared that the administration should push Congress to organize a new House Committee on Un-American Activities. According to the former Speaker, who has not been shy about his desire to become part of the new administration: "We passed several laws in 1938 and 1939 to go after Nazis ..... We're going to presently have to take similar steps here in regards to Muslims."

The anxiety, and the fear induced by xenophobia permeating through much of, non white, post-election society is palpable. This was aptly articulated when a member of the cast of "Hamilton," actor Brandon Dixon, asked Vice-President Elect Mike Pence, after he attended  a performance, to listen to this message: "We sir, we are the diverse America who are alarmed and anxious that your administration will not protect us, our planet, our children, our parents, or defend us and uphold our inalienable rights. But we truly hope this show has inspired you to uphold our American values, and to work on behalf of all of us - all of us!

Enough said.





Thursday, November 17, 2016

ELECTION 2016 - WHAT HAPPENED, AND WHAT IS NEXT?

This post was supposed to be titled "What's Next?". While the answers to this question are now probably more important than ever, the first thing that comes to mind right now is "What Happened?"

While  most analysts, pollsters, and political pundits are busy explaining why they were wrong predicting a vastly different outcome, some will suggest that there were indicators that Donald Trump winning the election, while surviving a brutal campaign, was not entirely unexpected. Some experts, perhaps afraid to end up on the wrong side of the prognosis, timidly cautioned not to forget what happened in the U.K. earlier this year when Britons were asked, in a referendum commonly referred to as "Brexit," whether or not to stay in the European Union. Polls massively predicted a "stay" vote, only to be stunned by a 52% to 48% defeat.

The similarities to what happened in our election are striking. Both countries, and for this matter most continental European countries as well, are experiencing a populist surge. While an increasing exhibition of populist anger has been recognized during election campaigns, the phenomenon infrequently developed into a predictable threat to real power. Because of labels like "ignorant" and "degenerate" the establishment attempted to attach to this group, a substantial number of these voters remained publicly silent about their intentions. In the U.S., as well as in Great Britain, this silent electorate produced largely unexpected election results.

We are engaged in a cultural civil war. A struggle between a mostly rural, blue collar, older, mostly white population segment which feels estranged from the social and demographic trends that are reshaping their country, against multi-cultural urbanites, social liberals, immigrants and minorities, supported by a status-quo elite structure that has ignored them. Populist demagogues across the spectrum successfully corral this sentiment, and provide simplistic answers to real problems. Instead of suggesting the workable solutions complicated challenges demand, they provide scapegoats like globalization, immigration, trade agreements, and government failure. "Let's Make America Great Again," in reality, becomes "Let's Make America White Again." Our election was about "restoration" against "transformation." It was not just about "change." For populists it was about turning the clock back to a more traditional time. The concerns about losing jobs and the elimination of entire industries is not just about losing income and obstructing a path to joining the middle class. It is about ending the progression of the social and demographic changes that threaten the identity of many lost in their own country.

Politicians leading this civil war view it as a revolutionary movement. Nigel Farage, head of the United Kingdom Independence Party, who led the campaign for Brexit, was energized by Donald Trump's electoral success, proclaiming: "The revolution continues!

So, what's next?
There will be plenty of time to assess the aftermath of the election when we move into 2017. We can only contemplate some of the following:

* The wall along our southern border could become a reality, even if Mexico won't pay for it.
* The Affordable Care Act (a.k.a. Obamacare) is on life support. The insurance of 20 million people could be at risk.
* The Trans Pacific Partnership treaty is dead.
* Judge Merrick Garland's elevation to the Supreme Court is dead.
* The Iran Agreement is in trouble. However, since this is a multi-lateral agreement, us pulling out won't kill it.
* NAFTA could be in trouble.
* Eleven million undocumented workers and three million American Muslims are worried about their future status, especially now that Steve Bannon, Executive Chairman of The Breitbart News, an explicitly racist organization, has become Chief Strategist and Senior Counselor to the President-Elect.
* Impeachment of Hillary Clinton is now off the table. However, House Republicans are planning to "continue investigating her for years to come."
* Mike Pence won't be running for President in 2020.
* The Democratic Party is fielding calls to replace the Electoral College with a system using only the popular vote when selecting a President. This movement gained traction after the 2000 election, and since Clinton could well end up with 2 million more votes than Trump, the issue has again become popular.

A friend of mine composed a list of 123 promises candidate Trump made during the campaign. Supporters and opponents of the President Elect will surely maintain a running tab on what President Trump will actually follow thru on. As David Miliband, a British Labour Party politician, observed, when confronted with the Brexit vote in the U.K.: "Populism is popular until it gets elected - then it has to make decisions." The proof, as they say, is in the pudding.

Friday, November 4, 2016

THE END IS NEAR - 270 OR BUST!

It is (almost) all over but the crying, grumbling, whining, growling, or complaining, whichever verb you might select to express your sentiment if you end up having supported the losing side in this year's presidential election. It is fair to say that the entire world will be holding its collective breath in anticipation of the outcome. And even though we are only a few days away from what some would refer to as "Armageddon" -  the final battle between the forces of good and evil - nobody predicts that the last days before November 8 will be uneventful. 

With all the venomous rhetoric spewed throughout the campaign, what will happen after the election is finally over is still very much in question. Nevertheless, this is decision time, and we are compelled to do our civic duty. As Theodore Roosevelt aptly observed: "In any moment of decision, the best thing to do is the right thing, the next best thing is the wrong thing, and the worst thing you can do is nothing." Before we begin to express concerns about potential implications of the outcome of this election, we should focus on how that decision is actually reached.

Most of us are aware that the popular vote does not decide the election. We vote for electors who represent us in the Electoral College. The number of electors each state is allotted is equal to the number of members of Congress to which they are entitled. Combined, these amount to 538 electors. This means that the winner will need to collect 270 electoral votes to be elected President. Most states use a winner take all system. Maine and Nebraska allocate their electors by Congressional District. Once the votes are in, the Electoral College meets the first Monday after the second Wednesday in December to officially verify the outcome. This year that will be December 19.

While all states participate in the election, the real battle takes place in so-called "battleground" or "toss-up" states. Democrats traditionally control the outcome on both coasts, with the possible exception of Florida, while Republicans have historically exerted more of a strangle-hold on the central and southern states. This year the dynamics could prove to be somewhat different. The Associated Press has rated 278 electoral votes to be safely Democratic. Their list of toss-ups include: North Carolina, Florida, Ohio, Nevada and New Hampshire, totaling 72 electoral votes. The Republican nominee needs to win all of these to have a chance at reaching the 270 target. Other states that could be in play are Colorado, Pennsylvania, Virginia, and possibly even Arizona and Georgia, both traditional Republican strongholds. In Utah, which has traditionally voted safely Republican, a political unknown, Evan McMullin, could have a shot at winning that state's election. Another race to watch, if for no other reason than curiosity, is the Senate race in Louisiana, where ex KKK Grand Wizard David Duke is, again, attempting to get elected. An estimated 50 million plus votes will already have been cast before we get to November 8. A very sizable percentage, considering that we have 146 million registered voters, of which only 126 million voted in the 2012 election.

Aside from the selection of a new President, 469 congressional seats are up for election as well, 34 Senate seats and all 435 House seats. Republicans control 246 seats in the House of Representatives, while Democrats occupy 186. Three are vacant. To retain control of the House, the GOP can lose no more than 29 seats. The Cook Political Report has rated 57 seats as "competitive."

On the Senate side the battle for control is significantly tighter. If Clinton is elected, Democrats need to turn 4 Republican seats to get control of the Senate, 5 if Trumps gains the presidency. (Democratic VP candidate Tim Kane would hold the tie breaker in a Clinton administration.) Republican incumbents at risk are: Mark Kirk, Illinois; Ron Johnson, Wisconsin; Kelly Ayote, New Hampshire; Patrick Toomey, Pennsylvania; Rob Portman, Ohio; Marco Rubio, Florida; and the open seat in Indiana contested by Democrat Evan Bayh and Republican Todd Young. In Nevada the seat being vacated by Senator Harry Reid, a Democrat, could be in play for the GOP. Leaders in both parties consider the battle for control of the Senate almost as significant and consequential as the contest for the White House.

Local candidates, bundled with a myriad of initiatives, dot the ballots in every state. Proposals covering the death penalty, marijuana reform, gun control, tax proposals and others are presented in hundreds of ballot initiatives offered up in states across the country. Throughout the years some of these have been real odd-balls. It has not been unusual to find ballot measures like: "Should we prohibit toxic waste in our drinking water?" (1986); "Should a police officer get to walk his beat with a ventriloquist dummy?" (1993); "Should we give $1 million to one random voter?" (2006).Or, as we see on our California ballot this year: "Should porn actors be required to wear condoms?"

Donald Trump recently proclaimed: "We should just cancel the election and declare me the winner." Hillary Clinton's team seems to be confident that their candidate is the odds on favorite to be elected President. While confidence promotes optimism, we should keep in mind what happened during the 1948 election between President Truman and Governor Dewey. With Dewey well ahead in all the polls, the Chicago Daily Tribune jumped the gun and announced in its morning edition on November 3rd that "Dewey Defeats Truman," only to be confronted with what has been called "the greatest upset in our history." (Truman beat Dewey by 114 electoral votes.) 

Something to consider when we watch the returns coming in. It is not over until it actually is. What happens next will depend on who wins.

Saturday, October 22, 2016

WHAT DO YOU HAVE TO LOSE? - LESSONS FROM WEIMAR

Sex, lies and videotapes appear to dominate the dialogue this election cycle. Our electorate seems to be more focused on character traits than on policy proposals. Chances are that eligible voters will select their choice for President based on leaks and innuendo, rather than on what they believe their collective votes will mean for the future of our country. Unfortunately, many are unable to see the forest for the trees. They are unable to understand, or unwilling to consider, the consequences of their selection, because they are concentrating on all the surface noise. Buyer beware!

George Santayana, a Spanish philosopher, has been quoted saying: "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it." The recent influx of populist movements across the globe, and their influence on the political discourse at home and abroad, has reminded some of us of the populist uprising that took place in Germany immediately following World War One. It could be beneficial to look at how our current political environment resembles relevant influences that were dominant in Weimar Germany.

While trying to recover from the effects of losing the war, German leaders attempted to create a modern liberal democracy. In a country that had up to then only known militarism and authoritarian monarchy, this proved to be difficult. The Treaty of Versailles, signed in June of 1919, required Germany to take full responsibility for the loss and damage during the war, forced it to disarm, make territorial concessions, and pay $31.4 billion in reparations (equal to $442 billion in 2016 money). The Weimar Republic confronted obstacles at every turn. The terms of the Treaty were impossible to comply with. Simultaneously, and legislatively, the Russian revolutions of 1917, and the consequent influence of the Communist International, effectively prevented cooperation among the strongest political parties represented in the Reichstag. When the world descended into the "Great Depression" the end was in sight. By the election of 1933 "Weimar" was effectively done.

With "war guilt" hanging over everyone's head, an economy in shambles, unemployment rampant, and the national parliament unable to agree on even the simple things, a populist belief in the power of regular people, and in their right rather than that of a small group of political insiders or wealthy elite, to control their government, took hold. Adolf Hitler, leader of the Nazi Party (NSDAP) co-opted the national mood, and translated its sentiment into a political platform that contained: opposition to "Versailles," cultural superiority of the Aryan race, anti-Semitism, anti-Communism, anti-parliamentarianism, anti-immigrant, Germany first, and economic isolationism. With support of the disenfranchised middle class and an autocratic elite, Hitler parasitized the movement, and shifted it to the ideological right. Six days before the 1933 elections, Nazi storm troopers unleashed a campaign of violence against the Communist Party, trade unionists, the Social Democratic Party, and the center-right Catholic Party. Even so, Hitler only received 43.9% of the vote, and needed to coalesce with the German National People's Party to give the NSDAP a tiny majority in the Reichstag. With their help he was elected Chancellor. Within two weeks he acquired dictatorial powers, and within months all other parties were banned. We know the rest.

So, what do we learn from this? What was once considered an anomaly, has become a trend. Nationalist and populist politicians have begun to assume power in many countries. The end is nowhere in sight. Ant-Semitism, in many places accompanied by Islamophobia, is cropping up all over. The migrant crisis in Europe revived a strong sense of populism. In country after country, anti-immigrant attitudes are blended with a nativist sentiment, focused on effecting cultural purification. Racial profiling, anti-trade, anti-globalization, and economic protectionism arguments feed into discussions similar to those prevalent during the troubled Weimar experiment. Messianic and pathological narcissists have taken center-stage in a growing number of countries. Russia has Vladimir Putin. Hungary elected Viktor Orban and his far-right Fidesz party on the premise of keeping migrants out, and keeping Hungary's national identity pure. In Poland Jaroslaw Kaczynski and his Law and Justice Party are converting its constitution and judicial system to more closely reflect an authoritarian past. The National Front, France's third largest party, is lead by politicians who once proposed to use the Ebola virus to take care of France's "immigration problem." On December 4, Austria will most likely elect Norbert Hofer its first Neo-Nazi President since World War Two.
And the Philippines just elected a new President, Rodrigo Duterte, who has already been accused of having his hand in the death of as many as 4,000 suspected drug offenders, while joking about the Holocaust. In this country our populist contender for the presidency, while subscribing to all the elements feeding into these pathological political positions, has suggested that, if successful, he would jail his opponent. If he loses, he appears disinclined to accept the outcome. Some of his supporters are already on record promising to start an insurrection.

While considering these worrying trends, I could not help but remember a poem by the anti-Nazi theologian Martin Niemoller:
"First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out - because I was not a Socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out - because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out - because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak for me."
My mother warned me in the late 1940's that "next time they will come for the Catholics." In 1942 they did come for my grandfather, a butcher, who was accused of feeding the Jews in our community. He was convicted and sent to the gallows in the Nazi re-education camp in Lahde, Germany.

I am far from predicting another holocaust. However, I am suggesting that when pathological narcissists assume power, nothing is off the table.
"What do you have to lose?" is not a rhetorical question.

Thursday, October 6, 2016

WE NEED TO RAISE THE BAR - SO, WHY ARE WE WATCHING A LIMBO CONTEST?

In a New York Times column published March 2 of this year Thomas Friedman observed that: "The three largest forces on the planet - technology, globalization and climate change - are in simultaneous nonlinear acceleration. Climate change is intensifying. Technology is making everything faster and amplifying every voice. And globalization is making the world more interdependent than ever."

To state that the world today is significantly more complex than it was around the middle of the last century has become a cliché. Complexity, a concept used to characterize something with many parts, interacting with each other in multiple non-linear ways, is something we face every day. Business leaders routinely postulate that "uncertainty + complexity = today's reality." Globalization, defined as a process of interaction and integration among the people, companies, and governments of different nations, driven by international trade and investment, and aided by information technology, forces our leaders to interact with a significantly different set of conditions than those encountered by their predecessors. In an article entitled: "Developing Leaders For A Complex World," Tamara Erickson, a leading expert on the topic, writes: "The complex and ambiguous conditions of this century are unlikely to respond to the old school of leadership. Old norms were honed in a different environment - one in which it was perhaps easier to view one position as right and the other as wrong, easier to predict, to forecast, to control." She and others suggest that today's leaders need to possess maturity, be able to grapple with ambiguity, and have a keen interest in collaboration - leveraging shared efforts and group processes.

Since all of this may sound like common sense, we should consider why some contestants for leadership positions at the pinnacle of our government act as if many of the most significant, and complex, issues confronting us are really simple and easy to fix. "Want to stimulate the economy? Cut taxes. Want to stop violent crime? Pass better gun control. Want to reduce our carbon footprint? Enact a cap and trade system. Want to stop illegal immigration? Build fences and hire border control agents." (Terry Newell, Simple Leadership in a Complex World." The Huffington Post, May 25, 2011). These slogan solutions are very popular in our electoral campaign world, but they are partial at best and dangerous at worst. They reflect a poor and often distorted understanding of the issues, while discouraging a more intelligent conversation. Albert Einstein said it best: "The significant problems we face cannot be solved at the same level of thinking where we were when we created them." Integrated problems demand integrated solutions.

We are regularly confronted with the unfortunate and stark contrast between the skills politicians advertise when campaigning, and the expertise required of them if and when they are elected. The excuse they use, however inadequate, is that the voting public won't take the time to understand complex discussions. The argument goes: We live in an age of attention deficit disorder, sound-bites, 30 second commercials, and bumper stickers. Many of us complain about technological change and increased complexity. We yearn for "simpler times." We project anxiety about the present, fear the future, and become nostalgic. The past is safe, because it is completely predictable. Our culture thrives on black-and-white narratives, clearly defined emotions, and easy endings. Rapid change is destabilizing. And politicians feed into this mind-set. They try hard to create zingers that are memorable and easy to grasp. Nevertheless, there is a difference between attaching "simplistic" solutions to complex problems, and using "simplicity" to make these issues more easily understood. To explain policy options in simplistic terms in effect involves a pejorative process which insults our collective intelligence. Simplicity, on the other hand, as Leonardo da Vinci told us "is the ultimate sophistication." And Steve Jobs cautioned that "simple can be harder than complex: you have to work hard to get your thinking clean to make it simple."

Friedman concluded that the accelerations he identified are raising the skill levels and life-long learning requirements for every good job. "They are raising the bar on governance, the speed at which governments need to make decisions, and the need for hybrid solutions. They are also raising the bar on leadership, [and require] leaders who can navigate this complexity." The challenges these accelerations pose require forcing a politics that is much more of a hybrid of left and right. So, while recognizing that much of our electorate may be more comfortable with the old school of leadership and with turning back the clock, the dynamics of our evolving world should require our politicians to demonstrate that they are cognizant of the need to raise the bar, and not insult us with sound-bites and platitudes. If we don't demand this, we allow them to continue to compete in a limbo contest.