Wednesday, February 27, 2019

ARE BILLIONS OF DOLLARS WORTH TALKING ABOUT?

In 2017, 39.7 million Americans lived below the federally established poverty level of an annual income of $24,600 for a family or four. Of these, 19 million live in deep poverty, meaning that their total family income is less than one-half of the poverty threshold. These people don't have enough resources to secure basic life necessities. For  most of them the inane discussion about the economics behind Donald Trump's $5.7 billion demand for support of his border wall, which forced 800,000 government employees to survive without a paycheck during the recent government shutdown, must have come across as incomprehensible and moronically insensitive.

Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, a wannabe billionaire (a contested $200 million shy of that goal), responding to reports that some government workers were relying on charity, homeless shelters and food banks, said: "I know they are, and I don't understand why." He suggested that those affected should be able to take out a loan, entirely missing the point when he rambled on: "We've had shutdowns, albeit for not such a long period as we've been thus far, but put it in the perspective: You're talking about 800,000 workers, if they never got their pay - which is not the case, they will eventually get it - but if they never got it, you're talking about a third of a percent on our GDP." (Quoted in "Real Clear Politics," Jan. 24, 2019.) Not to be outdone, Donald Trump, referencing an unsubstantiated annual price tag for illegal immigration of $250 billion, chimed in: "The $5 billion dollars ... is such a small amount compared to the level of the problem. It is insignificant compared to what we are talking about."

For the many wage earners who transitioned from viewing our national pastime of political infighting from the sidelines to confronting significant bread and butter issues for themselves and their families, this incredulously insensitive interchange between our national leaders must have come off as incomprehensible. Discounting the dollar value of the disputed wall, and reducing it to an "insignificant" percentage of GDP, should have disturbed everyone impacted by the shutdown. A billion dollars is $1,000 million dollars. If you have one billion, and spend $1,000 per day, you would be spending 2,740 years before going broke. You would need to pend $40 million per year - more than $3 million per month - to spend it all in 25 years. Considering that President Trump is demanding $5.7 billion as a down payment for a wall which ultimately is estimated to cost close to $25 billion, these number become difficult to make sense of for most of us.

Another way to understand the magnitude of the $5.7 billion price tag is to correlate it with more digestible expenditures. For instance, it equates to $17 per U.S. citizen, $40. per U.S. tax payer, about $18,750. for each one of the 304,000 apprehended undocumented immigrants during fiscal 2017, or $57,555. for each person requesting asylum in 2018. (The Wall Street Journal, Jan. 26, 2019). The eventual total estimated expenditure for this wall would virtually cover the cost of two of the navy's newest and most expensive "Gerald R. Ford-class" aircraft carriers, at $12.9 billion a piece.

Journalist and political commentator Nicholas Kristoff calculated that for $5.7 billion we could: "Send 100,000 at risk kids to a high quality pre-school for a year, AND provide Pell grants for 100,000 students to attend college for a full four years, PLUS provide comprehensive treatment to 115,000 Americans struggling with opioid addiction." (N.Y. Times, Jan. 15, 2019).

Our leaders may downplay the amount requested to erect this controversial monument to our president, reducing it to 0.03% of GDP, or, alternatively, discounting it to "only" 0.13% of our projected 2019 federal budget of $4.5 trillion, this is still a huge amount of money. We could probably use it more productively elsewhere.

Monday, January 21, 2019

NATIONAL EMERGENCY - A POTENTIALLY SUSPECT GAME CHANGER

Donald Trump has been boxed into an intractable position, more or less imposed by his biggest supporters. Mid-December he nearly signed legislation that would have funded the government, even though it lacked additional border wall funding. He signaled that he would sign legislation the Senate passed by acclamation. But when the House of Representatives was about to follow suit, right-wing personalities like Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity ad Ann Coulter blew a fuse. They publicly reminded the president of his central campaign promise to build a wall along the southern border, and argued that backing away from that promise was the equivalent of "caving in" (Breitbart), "retreating" (Drudge Report), and leaving him "dead in the water" (Coulter). Trump succumbed to the criticism, signaled he would not sign a continuing resolution that did not include $5.7 billion for his wall, and allowed the government to shut down. He effectively painted himself into a corner, using his "wall" as a symbolic and persistent centerpiece of ensuing negotiations, and led the government into its longest shutdown ever.

After the 116th Congress convened on January3rd, the Democrat controlled House passed numerous bills designed to re-open the government. None of these included money for Trump's wall. All of them faced opposition from Senate Majority Leader McConnell, who refused to bring them to the Senate floor for a vote. Mr Trump adamantly maintained that any legislation not including this  money would be dead on arrival. Democrats dug in their heels, demanding that the government be re-opened before debating the Homeland Security budget and funding for border security. Donald Trump's most recent offer to re-open the government by trading his $5.7 billion wall fund for temporarily shielding 700,000 DACA recipients and 300,000 refugees with temporary protective status fell flat, almost before it was issued. Some Trump supporters criticized the offer as "amnesty," while Democrats rejected it, called it "window dressing," continued to decline to support the wall, and refused to believe that the president would follow through on promises made.

While Democrats seem to sense that they occupy the political high ground and can hold out indefinitely, President Trump appears to be losing the P.R. battle, and is searching for ways not to blink. In other words, Mr. Trump is looking for an off ramp. A potential solution receiving significant traction within the administration is to declare a national emergency, followed by re-opening the government, and funding wall construction with funds derived from other projects. The president is confident that he has the absolute authority to do this, and that it would be a win-win solution for all interested parties. We should ask if he, in fact, can do this, and whether this solution would satisfy all parties involved.

Trump is correct in his assumption that he has the authority to do this. Legal scholars believe that the Constitution gives the president inherent emergency powers by making him Commander-in-Chief of the armed forces, and by giving him wide-ranging executive jurisdiction. Emergency powers are based on the idea that ordinary laws might be insufficient in a true crisis to deal with whatever that situation is. The president may need some temporary flexibility until the emergency passes, or until Congress has time to act and provide the authorities the president needs. At times, past presidents have taken actions that were not authorized, or specifically forbidden. Franklin Roosevelt's internment of U.S. citizens of Japanese descent during WWII and George W. Bush's programs of warrantless wiretapping and torture after the 9/11 terrorist attacks are examples.

In 1976 Congress passed the National Emergencies Act, designed to stop open-ended states of national emergencies and formalize the power of Congress to provide checks and balances on the emergency powers of the president. The Act does not define "national  emergency," does not create any criteria or requirements that have to be met, and does not require that the powers invoked relate to the nature of the emergency. Donald Trump laid the groundwork for this eventuality when he characterized the caravan of Central American migrants headed towards the U.S. border to seek asylum  a "national emergency," and when he asserted that the situation at the border constituted a "humanitarian crisis." Congress might contest this evaluation, but he has a legal right to his own interpretation.

The Brennan Center for justice at NYU School of Law calculated that once the emergency has been declared, the president would have access to emergency powers contained in 123 statutory provisions.  He could, for instance, declare martial law and use the military inside our borders. He could order the military to enforce immigration laws in sanctuary cities or states by claiming conspiracies. He could also determine that Americans inside the U.S. who offer material support to asylum seekers or, for that matter, to undocumented immigrants, pose a threat to national security, and authorize the Treasury Department to take action against them. And he could assume government control over internet traffic, to prevent the spread of disinformation or propaganda. In the mean time, wall construction could be litigated and be hung up for several years, well past the 2020 election.

While declaring a national emergency would allow Mr. Trump to escape the box his supporters placed him in, re-open the government, and to save face whether or not his wall is built, many in the country would be justifiably concerned that this move could become a precursor to the assumption of autocratic powers. Autocrats in Hungary, Turkey, Egypt and other places already employ similar methods. This could be tempting for a president backed into a corner and facing electoral defeat or impeachment. Declaring a national emergency could be a way of holding on to power.

Thursday, January 10, 2019

WILL EXECUTIVE PRIVILEGE DOMINATE 2019 POLITICAL DIALOGUE?

With Democrats dominating Republicans in the House of Representatives 235 to 199, leaving one seat still vacant, and in charge of all relevant committees, incoming committee chairs are expected to lead investigations into President Trump's long-hidden tax returns, possible conflicts of interest from his business empire, and any collusion between Russia and Trump's campaign team during the 2016 election. The White House, in turn, is expected to respond to many probing committee demands by citing "executive privilege," which would likely result in court battles, some of which reminiscent of "Watergate" in 1974.

"Executive privilege" is a power the Chief Executive claims to withhold information from Congress. The president and other members of the executive branch may use this assumed power to resist certain subpoenas and other interventions by the legislative and judicial branches of government in pursuit of information or personnel relating to the executive. Our Constitution does not explicitly mention that Congress or the federal courts have the power to obtain such information, nor is there any explicit mention of an executive privilege to resist such requests from Congress or the courts.

The concept an application of this presumed privilege became never more pretenious than during the Watergate hearings in the House of Representatives, and the consequent Supreme Court case in "United States v. Nixon." It involved the demand by Watergate special prosecutor Archibald Cox that President Richard Nixon produce the audio tapes of conversations he and his colleagues had in the Oval Office in connection with criminal charges being brought against members of his administration. Nixon invoked the privilege and refused to produce any records. Chief Justice Warren Burger, for a unanimous court, wrote that there existed a presidential communication privilege based on the system of separation of powers, which gives each co-equal branch of government broad latitude to function without interference of the other two. However, the Court held ultimately that the larger public interest in obtaining the truth in the context of a criminal prosecution took precedence. A related provision, articulated by Judge Patricia Wald of the D.C. Circuit, is the "deliberative process privilege," which holds that government officials should be free to privately deliberate before deciding on a particular course of action. But, again, this privilege disappears when there is any reason to believe that government misconduct occurred.

While "executive privilege" achieved notoriety during "Watergate," its use has by no means been restricted to the Nixon administration. In 1796 President George Washington refused to comply with a request by the House of Representatives for documents relating to the negotiation of the Jay Treaty between the U.S. and Great Britain. Thomas Jefferson refused to testify or provide private letters concerning Aaron Burr in his trial. Although the Supreme Court ruled against him, arguing that the Constitution did not exempt the president from court orders, Jefferson refused to testify personally, but provided selected letters. Between 1955 and 1960 President Eisenhower invoked the claim 44 times, in refusing to comply with subpoenas from the McCarthy Committee for transcripts of monitored telephone calls from Army officials and information on meetings between Eisenhower officials relating to the hearings. More recently, in 1998, President Bill Clinton invoked executive privilege on 14 different occasions, and lost in court when a federal judge ruled that Clinton aids could be called to testify in the Lewinsky scandal.

The current administration has already toyed with the concept. President Trump reportedly instructed or allowed aides to refuse to answer questions during congressional testimony. Both former White House Chief Strategist Steve Bannon and former Attorney General Jeff Sessions refused to answer questions respectively before the House and Senate Intelligence Committee on behalf of the president, "in case he wanted to claim it later." Former New York Mayor and current member of Mr. Trump's legal team Rudy Giuliani already stated publicly that any questions about obstruction related to the Trump presidency would fall under exective privilege, and would therefore go unanswered. As Robert Mueller is said to be close to wrapping up its obstruction inquiry, and is preparing a report of its findings, Trump's lawyers suggest that the information in it is protected by executive privilege. Therefore, the White House contends that it needs to sign off on the report's final version in case the Justice Department chooses to release it to Congress or the public.

Attorney General nominee William P. Barr, while Deputy, before becoming the A.G. during the George H.W. Bush administration, wrote: "Only when the accommodation process fails to resolve a dispute and a subpoena is issued does it become necessary for the president to consider executive privilege." ("Congressional Requests for Confidential Executive Branch Information," June 19, 1989.)

Any assertion of executive privilege may lead to a legal showdown in the courts, and could have serious political consequences. Excessive use of claims could create a weapon for impeachment, as both Clinton and Nixon discovered. With Democrats dominating investigative powers in the House of Representatives, and with jockeying for position in the upcoming 2020 election cycle already in full swing, 2019 could well provide ample fireworks on the hill.

Tuesday, January 8, 2019

IN SEARCH OF A U.S. FOREIGN POLICY

With an impetuous tweet, during the early morning hours of Dec.19, Donald Trump declared that the U.S. would withdraw all its troops currently fighting in Syria. This ill-advised decision was apparently predicated on the naïve notion that we defeated ISIS, and that it had been eliminated, even though 15,000 to 30,000 fighters remain in the area.

Politicians from both sides of the aisle quickly reacted angrily, expressing concern about giving ISIS another life-line, and essentially handing Syria over to Iran and Russia, both of which welcomed the development. Senator Bob Corker, outgoing chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, told reporters: "It's hard to imagine that any president would wake up and make this kind of decision, with little communication, with this little preparation." Republican Senators Graham and Rubio called the plan a "colossal and huge mistake," and Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis resigned in protest, worrying world leaders and U.S. allies who fear what an unchecked Trump might do.

Rubio, reacting to Mattis' abrupt resignation, expressed that the general's resignation letter confirmed fears about upcoming foreign policy decisions facing the Trump administration "that are going to undermine our security, that are going to undermine our alliances, and that are going to embolden our adversaries." The real point is that the president is making decisions by the seat of his pants, without the benefit of a cohesive foreign policy.

Analysts and practitioners agree that an effective foreign policy should include well-defined objectives to preserve national security, promote world peace in a secure global environment, maintain a balance of power through productive relations with international actors, promote a credible set of democratic and human rights values, and a cooperative involvement in international trade organizations. Allies and adversaries alike depend on a principled, intelligent and consistent approach. Given the chaotic conditions this administration tends to exhibit, be they intentional or incidental, policy development has sorely been lacking, with all resulting destabilizing consequences for the rest of the world.

Several of these foreign policy objectives overlap. These can't be fully developed within a column like this. However, a general overview should suffice to get the point across. In General Mattis' resignation letter he discusses the security element quite clearly: "One core belief I have always held is that our strength as a nation is inextricably linked to the strength of our unique system of alliances and partnerships. While the U.S. remains the indispensable nation in the free world, we cannot protect our interests or serve that role effectively without maintaining strong alliances and showing respect to those allies."

President Trump has made a habit of insulting our closest allies, threatening them with a trade war, showing a reckless disregard for their security concerns, while lavishing praise on contemporary autocrats like Kim Jong-Un, Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping, Recep Tayyip Erdogan and others. His decision to turn his back on allies that did most of the fighting against ISIS in Syria, the Kurds and Arabs, will leave them unprotected from a promised assault by Turkish forces. They are expecting a bloodbath. Right now, Turkish troops are already massing near the Kurdish-held Syrian town of Manbij, openly waiting for U.S. troops to be withdrawn. Jim Mattis and Brett McGurk, the envoy leading the international coalition fighting ISIS, who also resigned in protest, were indeed the adults in the room attempting, apparently unsuccessfully, to insure that Trump's bark was worse than his bite. Of course, our president has steadfastly maintained that he knows more than the generals.

Global security and stability depend to a large degree on predictability. Temperament and unpredictability have consequences. An erratic, irrational and unstable president influences our adversaries' threat perception, and increases the risk of miscalculation. Trump is entirely unpredictable, operates by the seat of his pants, impulsive, without thought-out policy prescriptions or strategy, and is apparently unwilling to consider international consequences.

Aside from emphasizing security and international relations, a credible foreign policy should reflect a set of values that support these objectives. During Trump's first year in office, the U.S. sharply downgraded its global pro-democratic posture. The president's support of dictators and criticism of democratic allies, as well as anti-democratic actions at home recast the country as at best an ambivalent actor on the global democratic stage. During his second year he doubled down on his embrace of dictators and spurning of democratic partners (Thomas Carothers, "Can U.S. Democracy Policy Survive Trump?," Carnegie, Oct. 1, 2018). The administration did at some point release a National Security strategy. However, it only emphasized protection against terrorism and increasing military strength. It omitted any mention of promoting human rights as a national security priority. Analysts believe that, done right, human rights strengthen, rather than weaken, American national security. Besides, strategies supporting unfocused, undeveloped objectives, are typically merely reduced to talking points.

If we want to maintain a measure of respect among those who have stood with us for the past 70 years, we need to get back to basics and develop and consistently pursue clear foreign policy objectives, not stab our allies in the back or, God forbid, leave them unprotected on the battle field. Anything short of that diminishes our moral standing, severely reduces our credibility in the world, and makes this a much more dangerous place.





Thursday, November 29, 2018

FEAR FUELS POPULIST RHETORIC

During the run-up tot the midterm elections, Donald Trump, in raucous stump speeches designed to energize his Republican base, made wildly inaccurate and baseless immigration claims, painting a doomsday scenario if Democrats were to take control of Congress. In rally after rally Trump exclaimed that: "Democrats are openly encouraging millions of illegal aliens to break our laws, violate our sovereignty, overrun our borders and destroy our nation in so many ways. We can't let that happen." He continued to assert that a caravan of a few thousand migrants moving north to the U.S. border consisted of MS-13 gang members, violent criminal and "unknown middle-easterners." Clams for which he never provided concrete evidence. (Ashley Parker et al., "Trump and Republicans settle on fear," The Washington post, Oct. 22, 2018).

While many of us in this country may have looked at his approach as a peculiar style Trump cultivated and applied during the 2016 election, assuming that it would work again this time around, the concept of spreading fear among electorates has become commonplace in an increasing number of countries dominated by populist, nativist and nationalist politicians. Populism has grown rapidly, its roots run deep, and analysts believe that the social and economic trends that have caused it will last long after the current crop of populist leaders has faded from the scene. Causes include: economic insecurity, social insecurity and political in effectiveness. Economic insecurity stems from income in equality, stagnation in average real in comes, and a drastically challenging labor market. Social insecurity comes from a perceived threat of immigration, generating cultural dislocation an loss of identity. And the feeling is that traditional political parties have become ineffective in coping with the dislocation fueled by globalization and technology.

Populism - a political doctrine that supports the rights and powers of the common people in their struggle with the privileged elite, targets lower income, less educated segments of the population, and plays on their fears of becoming economically irrelevant. Nativism, which seeks to protect the interest of native born or established inhabitants against those of immigrants, stresses the fear of losing cultural identity. Nationalism, in its extreme form of chauvinism, jingoism or xenophobia, develops as a direct result from exploiting these fears, and become dangerous when manipulated by crafty politicians.

Examples of the use of "fear" in political rhetoric to attract a compliant following have become ubiquitous. Viktor Orban in Hungary, often referred to as the "Trump of Europe," spent hundreds of millions of taxpayer money on ad campaigns conjuring up an atmosphere of hatred and fear of immigrants, promising to protect his nation against foreign enemies that, he said, are seeking to undermine its identity, integrity and sovereignty. In Italy, Mateo Salvini, who graduated from the position of Federal Secretary of the populist, neo-nationalist, Northern League, to, after recent elections, became Interior Minister and Deputy Prime  Minister, has declare a public safety emergency (even though Italy's crime rate has dropped for years), cracked down on immigration by facilitating deportation and severely restricting pathways to legal status, and loosened gun laws , making it easier for people to injure or kill intruders. In Germany, the anti-immigrant, Eurosceptic, AFD - Alternative for Germany - Party has become the third largest party in parliament. While impressive for a relatively new organization, in states that formerly belonged to Communist East Germany, the party clearly dominates,  achieving this status by praying on a long-simmering sense of discrimination, injustice an anger among those who, dating back to unification, never felt integrated in the overall society. After the influx of more than one million, mostly Muslim, refugees, the party projected even greater economic decline and cultural marginalization.

In extreme cases, the politics of fear practiced by populist politicians can become cataclysmic. Case in point, Germany post World War One. While Germany was weighted down by debt and feelings of defeat, Adolph Hitler promised to restore the country to its former glory. He spoke from an ultranationalist platform and positioned himself as a voice of the people against he government elite which brokered the Versailles Treaty and left the country weak and in debt. "Germany is broken, it needs to get up, to find its identity, it needs  leader, someone capable of restoring its character." (Tom Whipple, "From Hitler to Trump, Populist Leaders Profit form Fear," The Times, June 13, 2017.) We all know how that ended.

Globalization of the world economy, enhanced automation resulting from a destabilizing technological revolution which already eliminated many traditional occupations, and shifting demographic realities compounded by migration patterns fueled by conflict and despair elsewhere, threatening a cultural  mix natives no longer identify with, re causing distress among a growing segment of the population here and elsewhere. This extreme discomfort is real, and established governments have difficulty coping with a dynamically changing environment. Populist practitioners exploiting and exacerbating resulting fears may corral these disenfranchised groups to help themselves get elected. However, thus far they haven't shown an ability to solve underlying causes either. At best, they have succeeded in polarizing the political landscape, frequently making it more volatile and dangerous.

Wednesday, November 14, 2018

IN FLANDERS FIELD

Last Sunday, November 11, 2018, marked the 100th anniversary of the armistice signed in Compiegne, France, which went into effect November 11, 2018, marking the end of World War One, victory for the Allies and defeat for Germany. (The latter did not formally surrender.) This has been called "the Great War," by all accounts the most miserable and most brutal military conflict the western world has ever seen. Over 16 million military and 10 million civilian casualties were attributed to this "great" war. America mobilized 4 million combatants. Of these, 116,708 died, and another 204,000 were wounded.

The day before the anniversary our president was scheduled to honor the dead and lay a wreath at the Aisne-Marne American Cemetery in Belleau, 50 miles north of Paris. In 1918 the U.S. Marine Corps and French military repelled German forces in this location. More than 1,800 Americans died here, and 2,300 are buried in this cemetery. Because it was raining, Donald Trump decided not to bother doing the honors, and stay in more comfortable surroundings in the French capital. Our insensitive, void of empathy, Commander-in-Chief may not have cared about the expressions of incredulity from attending dignitaries and on social media, but the response was quick, and overwhelmingly negative.

Nicolas Soames, one of Winston Churchill's grandsons, tweeted: "They died with their face to the foe, and that pathetic inadequate Donald Trump couldn't even defy the weather to pay his respect to the fallen." Former Secretary of State John Kerry remarked: "These veterans the president didn't bother to honor fought in the rain, in the mud, in the snow - and many died in trenches for the cause of freedom." On social media a cartoon depicting a medic comforting a dying soldier with the caption: "It's OK marine ... some day in the future and American President will travel great distances to honor your sacrifice. Unless of course it's raining," was shared several hundred thousand times. Trump's insensitive reaction to mildly inclement weather generated myriad emotional responses, none uplifting. In the meantime, 92 year old Queen Elizabeth of England did attend a ceremony, braving the rain, credibly displaying empathy and a sense of responsibility.

My wife and I were fortunate enough to be able to attend the Hawaii World War One Centennial Commemoration at the War Memorial Natatorium near Waikiki in Honolulu. Since I became aware of the disgraceful disrespect exhibited by someone we supposedly elected to lead us in honoring those who gave everything for our freedom, I experienced emotions that were difficult to shake, became teary-eyed, and ashamed for our country. The opportunity to participate in Hawaii's commemoration ceremony helped take the edge off.

Hawaii was still considered a territory during WW1. However, on a per capita basis, this territory mobilized more of its citizens to active military service than any state or territory in the nation. A total of 9,800 Hawaiians served in uniform, mostly in the army. The depth and diversity of Hawaii's contribution were staggering. Native Hawaiians, as well as immigrant Chinese, Japanese and Filipino men all stepped up to serve. The ceremony was solemn, at times emotional, and was well attended by veterans of all ranks and cultures, government officials from dozens of countries, Governor David Ige and his wife, Mayor Kirk Caldwell, and Admiral John C. Aquilino, Commander of our Pacific Fleet. It featured a vintage Hawaiian, inclusive, Polynesian, multi-cultural ceremony, framed appropriately and respectfully by expressions of the nation's gratitude for the service of its veterans.

One of the most emotional presentations, leaving few dry eyes, was a recitation by First Lady Dawn Ige of John McCrae's poem "In Flanders Field."  These words, written in May 1915, only ten months after the conflict began, remain powerful today:

In Flanders fields the poppies blow
Between the crosses, row on row
That mark our place; and in the sky
The larks, still bravely singing, fly
Scarce heard amid the guns below.

We are the dead. Short days ago
We lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow,
Loved and were loved, and now we
lie in Flanders fields.

Take up our quarrel with the foe:
To you from failing hands we throw
The torch; be yours to hold it high.
If ye break faith with us who die
We shall not sleep, though poppies
grow in Flanders fields.

Someone should read this to Donald Trump, since he famously does not read, and explain its content. Then again, he probably won't get it.

Friday, October 5, 2018

SOCIALISM - A SLUR OR SIMPLY MISUNDERSTOOD?

During his Sept. 25 speech before the U.N. General Assembly, President Donald Trump called for the restoration of democracy in Venezuela by way of referencing historically ingrained biases. In his speech, produced by his Senior Advisor Stephen Miller, Mr. Trump proclaimed that: "Virtually everywhere Socialism or Communism has been tried, it has produced suffering, corruption and decay. Socialism's thirst for power leads to expansion, incursion and oppression. All nations of the world should resist Socialism and the misery that it brings to everyone."

While this may be just a snippet from the president's rambling speech, it appears to have been designed for domestic consumption, as well as to incite an international response, while regurgitating "red scare" propaganda from the 1920's and 1950's, conflating Socialism with Communism, and exhibiting a misunderstanding of Socialism and its role in some highly developed western democracies.

To be clear, Socialism and Communism, although linked in some political theories, are not alike. Communism is a political system. Socialism is an economic system. Karl Marx saw Socialism as a historical phase of economic development superseding Capitalism. The term refers to a system of social organization in which private property and the distribution of wealth are subject to social control. The conception of that control has been interpreted in myriad ways. Over time multiple paths by which Capitalism can best be turned into Socialism have been identified.

Pure Socialism has only been seen very rarely, usually in a few Communist regimes. Far more common are systems of social democracy, also referred to as democratic Socialism, in which the means of production (including wealth) are socially and collectively owned or controlled alongside a politically democratic system of government in the belief that it produces a fair distribution of income without impairing economic growth. (Donald F. Busky, Democratic Socialism: A Global Survey, Praeger, July 20, 2000).

In 19th century Marxist theory, Socialism was considered a transitional state between the overthrow of Capitalism and the realization of Communism. In reality, this is not what happened. During the 1920s and 1930s, even Hitler separated Communism from Socialism as being on opposite ends of a continuum. Moreover, Socialism did not produce suffering, corruption, et. as depicted in the president's speech. Near the top of a list identifying the 10 most socialist countries in the world (Peerform, Dec. 6, 2012), we find allies like Denmark, Finland, The Netherlands, Canada, Sweden, Norway and Ireland. These countries tend to feature large welfare programs, including universal free healthcare. They focus on developing an egalitarian lifestyle. It is notable that Denmark only spends 11 percent of its GDP on healthcare. We spend 18 percent. A list of countries on the "Quality of Life Index" show that Denmark, Finland and The Netherlands rank #1, 2 and 3. The U.S. ranks #9. Moreover, Norway has the highest standard of living in Europe.

Venezuela, by the way, is not considered to be a socialist country. It has a mixed economy, a compromise between government ownership of the means of production and free market Capitalism. Over 70% of its economy is comprised of private industry. The country has less central government spending than European social democracies.

In a way, Mr. Trump's misguided verbal attack on Socialism may be understandable. Public speeches, even those before an international audience, are designed to inspire a domestic audience as well. Cynics may remind us that during this election year Socialism has cropped up as an issue. In recently concluded primaries nearly two dozen candidates ran under the socialist banner on platforms that included healthcare for all, a $15 per hour minimum wage, free tuition and income equality. Newcomer, and self identified Socialist, Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez's primary defeat of Rep. Joe Crowly, the fourth highest ranking House Democrat representing New York's 14th district, sent shockwaves through both parties. The "Democratic Socialists of America," a group formed in 1982, has experienced an enormous surge of interest since President Trump was elected. Since November 2016, its membership increased more than seven-fold, from 6,000 to 45,000.

While Socialism seems to be losing its historic stigma in this country, there does appear to be a significant generation gap in its insurgence. In a 2015 Harvard Institute poll, a plurality of voters under 30 supported Socialism, dropping to 15% among those over 65.

Democratic Party leaders worry that talking openly about being a Socialist will make it harder to defeat Republican opponents. After all, the word "Socialist" has long been wielded by conservatives as a slur, associated with bad things in history.

Perhaps it would help to understand what we really are talking about.