Friday, September 28, 2018

THE 25TH AMENDMENT UNDERSCORES DYNAMIC STABILITY OF OUR CONSTITUTION

On September 5th, during the same week that Robert Woodward's book "Fear: Trump in the White House" was being promoted, The New York Times published an anonymous opinion piece entitled: " I Am Part of the Resistance inside the Trump Administration." The essay was attributed to a "senior official working for the Trump administration," criticize Trump, and stated that many members of the administration deliberately disobeyed or ignored suggestions and orders for the good of the country. The author wrote: "The root of the problem is the President's amorality. Anyone who works with him knows he is not moored to any discernible first principles that guide his decision making." Fairly common-place criticism frequently uttered by the opposition to the current administration. However, what seemed more intriguing was the assertion that some cabinet members during the early days of the administration discussed invoking the Twenty-Fifth Amendment to our Constitution in order to remove the President from power.

Predictably, politicians on all sides expressed their opinions about their relative desire to or the feasibility of using this constitutional tool to unseat our current President. Senator Elizabeth Warren, a potential presidential candidate in 2020, told CNN: "If senior administration officials think the President of the United States is not able to do his job, they should invoke the 25th Amendment. They can't have it both ways. Either they think the President is not capable of doing his job, in which case they follow the rules in the Constitution, or they feel that the President is capable of doing his job, in which case they follow what the President tells them to do." The Federalist's political writer David Harsanyi responded to the op-ed by opining: "The notion that the bureaucratic class in Washington should dictate which policies presidents are allowed to advocate simply by ignoring their wishes sounds a lot like a soft coup than a constitutionally principled resistance." Meanwhile, the White House appeared to be more concerned with uncovering the identity of the author than in discussing the essay's content. With all of this going on, the casual observer might justifiable ask: What exactly is the 25th Amendment to our Constitution, and how might it apply to the perceived situation at hand?

The Twenty-Fifth Amendment was proposed in Congress during the aftermath of the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, and was intended to clarify the succession process for the President or Vice President in the event of death, removal, resignation, or incapacitation. The amendment was sent to the states on July 6, 1965, and was adopted February 10, 1967. The amendment consists of 4 sections. The first three cover how succession is to be handled . This issue was left unclear and imprecise in the original Constitution. Until the adoption of the 25th Amendment succession of a President stipulated that the Vice President would take over as "Acting President" until the elected President could resume his (or her) duties, or until a new President was elected. If neither President or Vice President could do the President's job, Congress would decide who takes over. The first three sections clarify and formalize this process.

The critical section enumerated in the anonymous op-ed is section 4. It states: "Whenever the Vice President and a majority of either the principle officers of the executive department or of such body as Congress may by law provide, transmit to the President of the Senate and the Speaker of the House of Representatives their written declaration that the President is unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office, the Vice President shall immediately assume the powers of the office as Acting President." The President can subsequently transmit  written declaration that no inability exists, and resume powers and duties. Within four days the VP et al can restate their earlier transmissions, after which Congress would need to agree by a 2/3 vote. When it does, the VP will continue a Acting President.

Section 4 of the Amendment is both he most interesting and most difficult section to apply. It covers a case of inability when the President cannot or refuses to declare his own inability. Mid 20th century lawmakers anticipated a President whose instability might amount to disability. Multiple times during our history situations developed that could have fir the parameters of this section . James Garfield was bedridden after he was shot, Woodrow Wilson had a stroke in October of 1919, which was effectively hidden from the public, Dwight Eisenhower suffered a heart attack in 1955 and a stroke in 1957, yet no attempt was made to remove any of them from office. In fact, section 4 has never been used. It was contemplated  twice after the 1981 assassinated attempt on President Ronald Reagan. Given the sentiment displayed in the September 5 op-ed it should be noted that it was clear from the debates at the time of adoption and ratification that "unpopularity, incompetence, impeachable conduct, poor judgment and laziness do not constitute an "inability"  within the meaning of the amendment." (Jon Meacham, "Could the 25th Amendment be Trump's Downfall," Time , Jan 26, 2018.)

For all the hype and political grandstanding, the consensus seems to be that since the invocation of section 4 of the 25th Amendment requires buy-in from the Vice President, the majority of Trump appointed cabinet members, and 2/3 of the Republican controlled Congress, the entire concept is  a non starter. Ultimately, we should also recognize that our Constitution incorporates , what I would call,  dynamic stability. It allows us potential remedies for perceived grievances, but it won't be manipulated by political whim. Forcibly removing a President is a destabilizing event. Neither impeachment, nor invoking the 25thAmendment involve processes that can easily accomplish the intended result. Either might be used to release political steam. However, because of built in safeguards, neither has ever been used successfully. Deliberately or not, our Founders implied that the voting booth remains the  most secure democratic vehicle to affect desired change.

Friday, September 7, 2018

THE DEMOCRATIC PROCESS SHOULD NOT RESEMBLE GROWING MUSHROOMS

In 1787 our Founding Fathers met in Philadelphia in order to create a government that would be ruled by the people instead of by them. A cornerstone of this effort was the expressed need for systemic transparency and the unique privilege and responsibility of every citizen to be informed and engaged. The First Amendment to our Constitution intended to help accomplish this. In addition to freedom of speech, religion, assembly and the right to petition the government for redress of grievances, this amendment features "freedom of the press," which mean that citizens are allowed to circulate opinions in print without government censorship. Thomas Jefferson characteristically opined: "Were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers, or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter."

In 1766, twenty-five years before the passage of our First Amendment, the Swedish parliament became the first to pass a: "Freedom of the Press Act," abolishing the Swedish government's role as a censor of printed matter, and allowing official actions of the government to be made public. The concept of press freedom did not really become an issue until the 15th century when Johannes Gutenberg invented the printing press, enabling the mass production of books, newspapers, and other publications, which facilitated the spread of ideas faster an farther than ever before. Since some of these ideas tended to challenge official power structures, countless political and religious authorities actively suppressed publications they deemed subversive. (Britannica. com.) In the ensuing tug of war between those who insisted on controlling content and context of disseminated information, and those arguing that a free press was indispensable for people to stay informed an participate in a democracy, its influence has had much to do with the ultimate system of government countries adopted.

While autocrats favor controlling the flow and interpretation of information, democratic societies continue to stand behind freedom of the press, be it sometimes uncomfortably. They argue that: "The transparency that journalism brings to events makes government work better, decreases the risk of corruption, and ultimately makes our nation safer." (Linda A. Klein, "A free press is necessary for a strong democracy," ABA Journal, May 2017." Thy ideologically agree with Jefferson that: "Our liberty depends on the freedom of the press, and cannot be limited without being lost."

While the invention of the printing press led to a revolutionary increase in the spread of ideas, the growth of social media has prompted a vastly more sweeping growth of information technology and dissemination. Today unfiltered thoughts and ideas can be communicated to millions of recipients within minutes. Autocratic systems are finding ways of controlling flow, an subverting content. In democratic systems this is legally more difficult. Where desired, unfavorable press is often attacked by belittling its content, and identifying its substance as "fake news," as, supposedly, contrasted with official news.

Fake news, or deliberate misinformation, has been around for centuries. It is often indistinguishable from propaganda, as openly used by the Nazis, Communists and Fascists under the guise of "public enlightenment." More recently our own governmen5 has routinely confronted much of the nation's press with accusations of creating "fake news" as well, particularly when the disseminated information does not favor our president. The intent appears to be to undermine the veracity of criticism of the administration's policies and proposals, to substitute and obscure verifiable facts, and replace them with alternative facts.

To be fair, many residents have had contentious a contentious relationship with the press. Such are the trappings of a healthy democracy. However, the current administration has elevated its distaste for the legitimate press by being blatantly vitriolic. It regressed from characterizing unfavorable press as "fake news" to demonizing unfriendly media as the "enemy of the people," a term introduced by Joseph Stalin almost a century ago for the purpose of annihilating individuals who disagreed with him. Donald Trump, at his rallies, has made a point of identifying journalists as "horrible, horrendous people." His objective has clearly been to silence unfavorable ideas and conceal inconvenient reporting.

Trump's barrage of media attacks has had a measurable effect on the Republican Party. By the end of last year, just fourteen percent of Republicans said they still trusted the media. (John Cassidy, "How to counter Donald Trump's War on the Media," The New Yorker, August 3, 208.) Trump's announcement: "Don't believe the crap you see from these people, the fake news... what you're seeing and what you're reading is not what's happening," is shockingly reflective of a key point made by George Orwell in "1984:" "The party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command."

To quote Thomas Jefferson again: "No government ought to be without censors, and where the press is free, no one ever will. I think it as honorable to the government neither to know, nor notice, its sycophants or censors, as it would be undignified and criminal to pamper the former and persecute the latter." (1792).

Any self-respecting flourishing democracy embraces freedom of the press. In fact, it can't exist without it. Authoritarian regimes know that their survival depends on operating without the eyes and ears of the press upon them. In trying to undermine news coverage, President Trump is attempting to enjoy the same luxury. (John Diaz, SF Chronicle, July 29, 2018). As the sociologist DaShanne Stokes has pointed out: "Fascism thrives in obscurity and darkness."

Our democracy will not survive or grow by feeding people B.S. and keeping them in the dark. That's how you grow mushrooms.

Tuesday, July 31, 2018

WILL TRUMP BE COMPLICIT IN DISMANTLING NATO?

In April of 1949 the United States and 11 Western European countries signed an agreement establishing the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) to provide collective security against the Soviet Union. The most significant clause in this treaty was "Article 5," in which signatories agreed that "an armed attack against one or more of them.... shall be considered an attack against them all." Following such an attack each ally would take "such action as it (considered) necessary, including the use of armed force". In retaliation, in 1955, the Soviet Union and its Eastern European satellite states formed the Warsaw Pact. Aside from the USSR, this group included Albania, Poland, Romania, Hungary, East Germany, Czechoslovakia and Bulgaria. Fast forward 70 plus year, after the end of the Cold War and the fall of the Soviet empire, all of these former satellite states are now part of NATO, a significant thorn in the side of Russia's current autocratic leader Vladimir Putin.

Putin, a foreign intelligence Lieutenant Colonel in the KGB for 16 years, has effectively run the Russian government ever since President Boris Yeltsin appointed him on August 9, 1999. He continues to articulate his disenchantment with Russia's diminishing strategic power and influence vis-à-vis NATO and the European Union, and he has been vocal about what he considers to be an existential threat to his country from these two organizations. He is dedicated to weakening the EU and undermining the NATO military alliance to extend his power and potentially recover a hegemonic role for Russia. In his mind the collapse of the USSR was the greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the 20th century. The fact that 10 formerly Communist states joined the EU rubbed additional salt into Russian wounds. As a former KGB puppet master Putin initiated subtle, and not so subtle, attacks on his adversaries.

It should be understood that nothing significant emerging from Russia happens without Putin's consent. In 2007, Estonia, which with six other Eastern European nations joined NATO in 2004, suffered a crippling cyber attack, essentially shutting down the entire country, solely because, contrary to explicit warnings emanating from Moscow, it removed a Soviet WWII memorial from its capital's downtown. In 2008, after Georgia expressed an interest in joining NATO, Russia invaded its provinces Abkhazia and South Ossetia, ultimately declaring them independent states, and regrouping them under the Russian umbrella. In 2014 Russia invaded Ukraine and annexed the Crimean Peninsula. Later that year, the 53rd Anti Aircraft Rocket Brigade of the Russian Federation shot down a Malaysia Airlines passenger jet over rebel territory in Ukraine, killing all 298 on board. In 2016 Russia plotted to overthrow Montenegro's government and assassinate its Prime Minister, Milo Djukanovic, to sabotage that country's plan to join NATO, something they did a year later anyway. That same year, allegedly with support of the Federal Security Service, successor to the KGB, and the GRU, the military intelligence service, Russia effectively meddled in the British "Brexit" referendum, supporting the "leave" campaign headed up by Nigel Farrage. Subsequent Russian interference in the U.S. and French elections has also been well established. In the meantime dozens of Putin's critics died violently or disappeared altogether. Boris Nemtsov - shot in the back in front of the Kremlin, Alexander Litvinenko - poisoned with Polonium 210, and Sergei Magnitsky - killed in prison, are cases in point. In short, Vladimir Putin will stop at nothing to accomplish his objectives. He is the consummate professional KGB officer, accomplished puppet master, a merciless killer, and no friend of the West.

President Trump's open skepticism of NATO, its continued relevance, and the viability of "Article 5" of its charter, mouthing Russia's talking points, is playing into Putin's hands. During an interview on Fox News Trump explicitly questioned why an American would have to defend a small country like Montenegro, which is more than 5,000 miles away. Qualifying and conditioning the notion of NATO's defense guarantee is a major step towards abandoning it. The only time in history when the Article 5 guarantee was invoked was after 9/11. Our allies sent tens of thousands of troops to fight alongside Americans in Afghanistan, spent tens of billions of dollars, and suffered more than 1,000 casualties in defense of an ally. Georgia and Ukraine were invaded with impunity, without eliciting military retaliation, because they did not belong to the NATO alliance.

After Trump's private meeting with Putin in Helsinki, and subsequent to his submissive participation in their press conference, patriots on both sides of the political aisle, and most of our allies who stood by us for 70 plus years, questioned U.S. bias and commitment after the president publicly challenged the veracity of his own intelligence experts while chastising NATO and branding the EU a "foe," again effectively doing Putin's bidding. Former CIA director and career intelligence officer John Brennan tweeted that Trump's performance in Helsinki "rises to and exceeds the threshold of 'high crimes and misdemeanors.' Nothing short of treasonous," while calling his comments "imbecilic, wholly in the pocket of Putin." Rumor has it that one of the items the two leaders agreed to is that Georgia and Ukraine  will never be allowed to join NATO. Not entirely unexpectedly, Russia's foreign minister Sergey Lavrov asserted that the summit results were "better than super," while our own senior staff appeared reticent about discussing the meeting's content at all.

By tweeting that: "Our relationship with Russia has NEVER been worse thanks to many years of US foolishness and stupidity, and now the Rigged Witch Hunt," (sic), Donald Trump either reflects ignorance, is gullible, or somehow beholden to the Russian dictator. As Charles de Gaulle, and numerous others following him, remarked: "No nation has friends, only interests." If Trump insists on inviting Putin to DC this fall, we are essentially bringing the KGB into the White House, the inner sanctum of our democracy. In some sense we are encountering a scene from a play detailing the onset of our revolution. The composite intelligence services play Paul Revere, screaming: "The Russians are coming, the Russians are coming." Unfortunately, someone also needs to play the role of Benedict Arnold.....

Tuesday, July 3, 2018

ONE STEP CLOSER TO THE ABYSS

Donald Trump is frustrated, suffering from a severe dose of "relative deprivation," the conscious experience of a negative discrepancy between his expectations and political reality. Trump is frustrated in part because he has been unable to secure funding for his signature campaign issue of building a wall along the length of our southern border. Mexico won't pay for it, and Congress has not been able to secure the votes to do so either. Given this reality, it is not difficult to imagine that Mr. Trump, with assistance of his senior advisor Stephen Miller, a former aide to then Senator Jeff Sessions, and well known for echoing white supremacist and anti-immigrant viewpoints, would conjure up a strategy intended to create a hostage situation designed to shame Democrats into helping move a Republican backed immigration measure across the line in Congress.

On April 6 Trump issued a memorandum ending "catch and release" at the border, a practice which releases illegal immigrants from detention while they wait for their immigration court hearing. He directed Homeland Security, the Justice and Defense departments to come up with measures they would be able to take to end this practice. Attorney General Jeff Sessions subsequently ordered federal prosecutors to adopt a "zero tolerance" policy. A month later he clarified what he really meant: "If you cross the border unlawfully, then we will prosecute you. If you smuggle illegal aliens across our border, we will prosecute you. If you are smuggling a child, then we will prosecute you, and that child will be separated from you as required by law. If you don't like that, then don't smuggle children over our border." Six week later 2,300 plus kids had been separated from their parents, interred into wire cages, forced to sleep on concrete floors, housed in warehouses and internment camps reminiscent of conditions that existed in the camps Japanese-Americans were forced into during World War II. To avoid transparency, the press and elected representatives were denied access to these hastily erected internment facilities.

As the reality of this process became clear, its consequences quickly generated overwhelming critique from every corner of the country, and from the world at large. The 47-member United Nations Human Rights Council, which began its latest session on June 18 with a broadside against Mr. Trump's immigration policy by the High Commissioner for Human Rights, called the policy of separating children from parents crossing the southern border illegal and unconscionable. The next day the Trump administration announced its withdrawal from the council.

Instead of immigration reform, kids in cages, considered child abuse by many, became the focus for politicians of both parties, people from all faiths from the Vatican on down, and from all First Ladies still living. While acting like ventriloquist dummies, A.G. Jeff Sessions, and Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen, remained unapologetic in their support of Trump's policy. Sessions justified his decision to separate families by citing a biblical admonishment from Apostle Paul in Romans 13 to "obey the law of the government, because God has ordained them for the purpose of order." In response, more than 600 clergy and lay members of the United Methodist Church, to which Sessions belongs, signed a letter opposing his viewpoint. In the mean time Trump doubled and tripled down on this policy, blaming Democrats for the problem. "They don't care about crime, and want illegal immigrants to pour into and infest our country, like M.S. - 13" [sic].

Trump, Sessions, Nielsen and other apologists continued their bombastic lies as international pressure mounted. Comparisons to Nazi-Germany's forcible removal of 400,000 children from their parents, and Putin's goons arresting kids first at anti-Putin rallies, began to surface regularly. Democratic leaders lamented that taking children from their parents was a form of state terror, and that hostage taking was one of the most effective tools of terror most of us never thought we would see an American administration implement. Trump finally appeared to back down and signed a Presidential Executive Order nominally halting the practice, a political document entirely unnecessary and still lacking clarification and follow-through. A day later the president followed up by featuring an event in the White House rose garden callously showing off families who were "permanently separated" from their children killed by illegal aliens. A few days later he proposed to deport asylum seekers immediately after crossing the border without extending to them their legal right to due process.

None of this should have surprised us. Donald Trump feels the need to project strength without restraint. He routinely indicates that he prefers "strong" autocratic leaders over our "meek, dishonest and weak" traditional democratic allies. His new-found friend Kim Jong Un, China's Xi Jinping, Egypt's Fatah al-Sissi, Turkish Erdogan, Russia's Putin and others appear to have more what our president looks for in a leader. Not surprisingly, none of these criticized him about his stance on immigration. While Trump refers to illegal immigrants as vermin infesting our country, they routinely and openly dehumanize migrants and other irritants as well. In the president's mind compassion and empathy are signs of weakness. He won't acknowledge that those are character traits that actually make us human. Given the chance, it would not be much of a stretch to imagine him rubbing shoulders with Hitler and Mussolini.

His relentless attacks on the free press, his disregard and disrespect for our laws and democratic institutions, even suggesting that he is above the law and could pardon himself, unilateral withdrawal from international agreements, and his perpetual lies leading up to and surrounding this disgraceful episode, makes us wonder how close we have come to the end of rules based democratic government in our country. London's King's College instructor Angelos Chryssogelos, in a May 31, 2018 Time magazine article, warned: "Populism can indeed become a threat to democracy if populists in power undermine liberal institutions and enable illiberal democracy that can, with time, degenerate into outright electoral autocracy."

Mussolini was known for having said that "if you consolidate power by plucking a chicken one feather at a time, people won't notice." Trump is considerably less subtle, he plucks them out by the fistful. We need to pay attention. The abyss lies at the bottom of a slippery slope.

Wednesday, May 23, 2018

A LIBERATION REMEMBERED

On May 5, The Netherlands, the country in which I grew up, commemorated the 72nd anniversary of liberation from the brutal occupation by Nazi Germany during World War II. If my parents were still alive today, they would almost certainly have expressed relief, but most likely have declined to celebrate that moment in history. After all, liberation from intense war-time occupation differs fundamentally from gaining independence from colonial subjugation. Too many horrible, life-changing, memories clouded the experience removing the Nazi occupation force must have generated.

The Netherlands' involvement in WWII began when Nazi Germany invaded the country on May 10, 1940. Although it had attempted to remain neutral, Hitler ordered its invasion anyway. After only four days of intense fighting between an ill-equipped Dutch military and an overwhelming German force assembled to execute its "blitz Krieg," and after the May 4 bombing of Rotterdam, the Dutch army surrendered. During this "Rotterdam blitz," 800-900 Dutch civilians were killed, and 25,000 houses were destroyed. The royal family initially evacuated to London, and subsequently moved to Canada for the duration of the war. In a country with, at the time, had a population of less than 9 million people, 198,000 civilians were killed and 7,900 military lost their lives during this war. In addition, 102,000 Jewish citizens were exterminated.

Holland's total population included 140,000 Jewish citizens, 70 percent of which lost their lives in extermination camps throughout the five-year period. This was a much higher percentage than what was experienced in comparable countries like Belgium or France. The Nazis did not begin to deport the Dutch Jews until early 1941. When they did begin this process the Dutch protested by going on strike. This response was unique in Nazi occupied Europe, but accomplished little, and all its leaders were summarily executed. The Germans and their Dutch collaborators gradually intensified anti-Semitic activity. For a price, members of the "Henneicke Column" identified as "Joden Jagers" (Jew huners) captured around 8,000 to 9,000 of the Jews that were in hiding, and delivered them to the German occupiers for deportation to the camps.

Atrocities applied to the civilian population were too numerous to detail. One significant illustration of the monstrous Nazi mindset was a series of events identified as the "Putten raid." Putten, at the time, was a small village in the center of the country. Following a resistance attack on a Wehrmacht vehicle, the Nazis, on October 1, 1944, burned 100 houses and removed 601 men, almost the entire male population of the village, and deported them to various concentration camps. Only 48 of these returned at the end of the war.

I was born four months before the end of the war, entirely unaware of what was going on around me. Before I could read, my mother was my main source of information about the horrors Dutch civilians endured during these fateful five years. My dad remained stoic, and remained less interested in discussing all that had happened, perhaps still shell shocked, or feeling guilty that he had not prevented all his family had experienced.

On one afternoon in 1942 he returned from a bad day at work to find out that his father, a butcher, had been arrested for hiding resistance fighters and feeding Jews. The Nazis picked him up without notice, sentenced him to 2.5 years of slave labor, sent him to the Gestapo prison "Ahlem" in Hannover, and subsequently imprisoned him in the re-education camp "Lahde." My family never saw him again. Upon being led away, my grandfather told his wife that he would write with ink if everything was O.K., and in pencil if it was not. All correspondence reaching Holland was in pencil. Although he completed his sentence in late 1944, and even though my family submitted a sizable ransom, the Nazis refused to release him. Every day during the last few months of the war, camp Lahde executed 10 or more prisoners on a scaffold erected for that purpose. My grandfather was killed March 11, 1945.

With exception of collaborators, nobody was ever safe. Periodically the Nazis would hold razias designed to arrest young men for work programs in Germany. On those occasions my dad would hide in between a double wall to avert detection. The Germans, to ensure they were not missing anyone, would use bayonets to puncture those walls, fortunately always missing their mark.

When in September of 1944 the allied advance was halted near Arnhem, the provinces located north of the Rhine were forced to endure continued Nazi domination and a severe winter with little or no food. Famine became especially intense in areas and cities outside of agricultural areas. People were forced to scrounge for food, which included rodents, flower bulbs, and anything ingestible found on garbage dumps. More than 20,000 people died of hunger and deprivation that winter.

So, May 5 is still commemorated with a sense of relief, but hardly celebrated. Memories are too painful. However, these anniversaries remain important, especially for generations with no direct connection, to show what can happen when fascism is allowed to proliferate, especially now that its ugly head is again rearing up all over the globe.

Sunday, May 20, 2018

IMPEACH TRUMP? NOT SO FAST!

President Donald Trump reluctantly signed the massive $1.3 trillion omnibus spending bill on March 23 while pointedly suggesting that he would never sign legislation like that one again. In response, conservative political commentator Ann Coulter, author of "In Trump We Trust," mocked the president by tweeting: "Yes, because you'll be impeached."

Whether conceptually, hypothetically, ideologically or reluctantly, impeachment has been on the lips and in the minds of many political activists, sometimes dating back to before Donald Trump's inauguration. As the political dialogue became more contentious, this discussion grew more intense, not just on the political left, but, be it for different reasons, among many Republican operatives as well. When the president appeared to be toying with the idea that he could somehow fire Special Counsel Robert Mueller or Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein, representatives from both sides of the congressional aisle warned that such a move could precipitate a constitutional crisis and potentially escalate political demands to start the impeachment process. To date as many as 60 House Democrats have signed on to a request to begin debating impeachment, a step opposed by the party's leadership as premature and counterproductive. A resolution voted on in December 2017 failed by a 58-364 margin. Nevertheless, Representative Maxine Waters, Al Green and Brad Sherman continue to push the issue, while billionaire donor Tom Steyer has embarked on a national "Need to Impeach" campaign, attending 30 town hall meetings in an attempt to get his point across.

Before we read too much into this incessant banter, we ought to take a look at what we are really talking about. Cass Sunstein, a legal scholar specializing in constitutional law, in "Impeachment American Style," published in The New Yorker of Sept. 20, 2017, gives us a historical perspective. The American colonies imported the concept from England, where Edmund Burke called it the "great guardian of the purity of the Constitution." When, in the summer of 1787, the Constitutional Convention accepted the idea of a powerful president, its delegates insisted on including the impeachment mechanism. In fact, the argument was made that, without he impeachment clause, the Constitution would never be ratified. Benjamin Franklin apparently observed that, historically, the removal of "obnoxious" chief executives had been accomplished by assassination, and suggested that a procedural mechanism for legal removal - impeachment - would be preferable. (Josh Chafetz, "Impeachment and Assassination," Minnesota Law Review, June, 2011).

To be clear, impeachment refers to the process by which a legislative body formally levels charges against a high official of government. It is only a formal statement of charges, akin to an indictment in criminal law. It is NOT removal from office. To begin the process, the president has to be charged with treason, bribery, or high crimes and misdemeanors. The House of Representatives, on the recommendation of the Judiciary Committee, votes on one or more articles of impeachment. If at least one of these gets a majority vote, the president is impeached, and the proceeding moves to the Senate. Overseen by the chief justice of the Supreme Court, the Senate holds a trial. A team of lawmakers from the House play the role of prosecutors, the president has defense lawyers, and the Senate serves as the Jury. If at least two-thirds of the senators find the president guilty, he is removed, and the vice president takes over as president.

Impeachment is a political act. There are no standard rules. The party in power traditionally decides how to interpret the charges and what the rules for the trial will be. Throughout our history only Andrew Johnson (1868) and Bill Clinton (1998) were successfully impeached by the House. Both were acquitted by the Senate. However, in Johnson's case the Senate vote was 35-19 in favor of removal - one vote shy of the requisite two-thirds majority. President Nixon (1974) resigned before the impeachment resolution could be voted on by the House.

With mid-term elections coming up at he end of the year, both Republicans and Democrats grapple with the impeachment prospect. When Ann Coulter predicted that the president would be impeached, she really warned Republicans that if a Democratic "blue wave" were to materialize, Donald Trump would run the risk of being impeached. Republican leaders are reportedly discussing framing their election campaign around the threat of impeachment, as a motivational tool for voter turnout. Corey Lewandowski, former Trump campaign manager, suggested that "the threat of impeachment is something that unifies everybody in the party, even if you're not a Trump supporter." Democrats, on the other hand, fear that the focus on impeachment may be a political trap that would distract from their core message, and boomerang them in November. According to Obama's former chief strategist, David Axelrod: "If impeachment becomes a political tool instead of the end result of a credible investigation, you are as guilty as Trump, in  some ways, of taking a hammer blow to institutions." (Charles Pierce, "Impeachment is the Republicans' Latest Boogeyman for the 2018 Elections," Esquire, April 9, 2018).

While both the left and the right appear poised to use impeachment as a wedge issue or a rallying cry, history tells us that the actual political process is thorough, slow, and tends to protect the incumbent. It rarely comes close to its intended conclusion.

Friday, March 23, 2018

"AMERICA FIRST" - ACTIONABLE POLICY OR ILL-INFORMED IMPULSE?

During his inaugural address on January 20, 2017, Donald Trump elicited significant pushback and raised many eyebrows when he proclaimed that: "From this day forward, a new vision will govern our land. From this moment on, it's going to be 'America First.' " Analysts wondered out loud if he intended to roll out a new period of isolationism, non-interventionism or economic nationalism. Conservative columnist Charles Krauthammer wrote that Trump's inaugural "radically redefined the American national interest as understood since World War II." Instead of exercising global leadership, the United States was now opting for "insularity and smallness." Conservative journalist Bill Kristol, founder and Editor-at Large of the Weekly Standard, lamented: "I'll be embarrassedly old fashioned here: it is profoundly depressing and vulgar to hear an American president proclaim 'America First.' "

It is questionable whether President Trump really understood what he proclaimed on the west lawn of the U.S. Capitol that afternoon. According to a corroborated report published by the Wall Street Journal, his speech was written by chief strategist Steve Bannon and senior advisor Stephen Miller, both of whom have long been associated with Breitbart and the white supremacist movement. They knew very well that "America First" historically stood for the "America First Committee," which was founded at Yale Law School in 1940. It was the foremost non-interventionist pressure group against American entry into WWII, and was characterized by anti-Semitic and pro-Fascist rhetoric. Membership peaked at 800,000 paying members in 450 chapters, and counted people like Charles Lindbergh, Walt Disney and Frank Lloyd Wright among its most prominent members. It was dissolved on December 10, 1941, three days after the attack on Pearl Harbor had brought the war to America. Professor Eric Rauchway of the history department at U.C. Davis summarized the "America First"  concept as: A white America, living behind higher walls and screens, lashing out to prove its strength and then retreating again - not a government suspiciously tolerant of foreign threats." (Eric Rauchway, "President Trump's 'America First' slogan was popularized by Nazi sympathizers," Washington Post, Jan. 20, 2017.)

Many who considered the use of this slogan, including, I suspect, Trump himself, may have understood it to refer to some measure of isolationism, a policy or doctrine of trying to isolate one's country from the affairs of other nations by declining to enter into alliances, foreign economic commitments, international agreements, and generally attempting to make one's economy self reliant. In its purest form, isolationism is a nation's total retreat from the world stage, something we attempted at various time throughout our history, dating back to the Founders. Our Founding Fathers saw America's geographical separation from Europe as an ideal opportunity to cultivate the new nation in solitude. George Washington suggested that: "Our detached and distant situation [from Europe] invites and enables us to pursue a different course. Thomas Jefferson warned against "entangling alliances." ("A brief history of American isolationism," The Week, June 5, 2016.)

Following the explosion of the battleship USS Maine in the harbor of Havana on February 15, 1898, which killed 260 U.S. sailors, President McKinley ended isolationism by declaring war on Spain. It was revived after the U.S. suffered 116,516 deaths and 320,000 sick and wounded during WWI. Our Senate voted 49-35 against joining The League of Nations, the international organization, substantially conceived by President Woodrow Wilson after the end of WWI to provide a forum for resolving international disputes, and pursued economic issues throughout the 1930's, ignoring the ascend of militaristic dictatorships in Europe and Japan. When war broke out with the invasion of the Sudetenland in 1938 and Poland in 1939, the isolationist Congress kept us out, and the war gave rise to the previously discussed "America First Committee."

Non-interventionism and isolationism, even though distinct, are frequently conceptually confused, while economic nationalism, or protectionism, is often seen as a subset of isolationism. Mr. Trump's expressed proclivity to impose tariffs on aluminum and steel, under the guise of national security and "America First," seems to underscore his confusion as well. The last time this country pursued a significant protectionist policy was during the Hoover administration when the president signed the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930, with tariffs on over 20,000 goods, which exacerbated the Great Depression, and led to retaliatory actions by other nations.

The jury is still out on Trump's protectionist inclinations - the Washington Post calls him a "novice protectionist" - however, it would be a stretch, and it would give the administration too much credit, to connect the president's I augural proclamation to significant policy prescriptions. " Ordering punitive strikes against a regime that murders its own citizens while posing no threat to the United States, as Trump did it Syria, is not isolationism." Nor is it non-interventionism. His intent to broker an Israeli-Palestinian peace deal, his threats against North Korea, and his views on the viability of NATO do  not suggest disengagement. (Andrew Bacevich, "Saving 'America First,' What Responsible Nationalism Looks Like," Foreign Affairs, Sept/Oct, 2017). "Policy" refers to a set of ideas or plans that is used as  basis for making decisions. Mr. Trump displays a chaotic mindset, unfocused on recognizable policy principles, which has already negatively affected our global leadership position. Given the administration's behavior during the past 14 months, "America First" appears to simply have been an ill-informed impulse, a slogan co-opted by speech writers expressing their personal political agenda.